New Research Finds Hydroxychloroquine No More Effective Than Placebo in Preventing COVID-19

13


Hydroxychloroquine COVID-19

Front-line health workers had similar infection rates whether they took a daily regimen of hydroxychloroquine or not.

In a clinical trial testing whether a daily regimen of hydroxychloroquine could protect those most likely to be exposed to COVID-19, researchers from the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania found there was no difference in infection rates among health care workers who took the drug versus those taking a placebo. While the researchers observed a lack of effect associated with hydroxychloroquine, infection levels were low among the participants, which the researchers believe points to the effectiveness of other prevention measures in the health system: social distancing, use of personal protective equipment, and proper hand hygiene. The study was published recently in JAMA Internal Medicine.

“This work represents the first randomized trial of hydroxychloroquine’s prophylactic effect for those not yet exposed to COVID-19,” said the study’s lead author, Benjamin Abella, MD, MPhil, a professor of Emergency Medicine and the director of Penn Medicine’s Center for Resuscitation Science. “And while hydroxychloroquine is an effective drug for the treatment of diseases like lupus and malaria, we saw no differences that would lead us to recommend prescribing it as a preventive medication for COVID-19 in front line workers.”

Due to the novel nature of COVID-19, the science and medical communities have had to rapidly assess treatment and prevention measures. One drug that has been considered as a potential preventive solution was hydroxychloroquine, based on laboratory studies that it could prevent SARS-CoV-2, the virus that causes COVID-19, from entering cells in tissue culture.

As such, Abella, along with the study’s senior author Ravi Amaravadi, MD, an associate professor of Medicine in Hematology-Oncology and the program co-Leader of Cancer Therapeutics at the Abramson Cancer Center, and their co-authors set out to rigorously test whether taking a substantial dose of hydroxychloroquine – 600 milligrams daily for two months- would have an effect on infection rates. They conducted this study among hospital workers that regularly came into contact with COVID-19 patients.

The researchers were able to analyze a pool of 125 physicians, nurses, certified nursing assistants, emergency technicians, and respiratory therapists that they recruited for the study. This population worked in several different areas of the two University hospitals, including the emergency departments and COVID-19 units. Roughly half of the participants in the study took hydroxychloroquine while the other half took a matching placebo (a cellulose pill). The study was double-blinded, meaning neither the researchers, nor the participants knew which drug they were assigned.

Extensive testing was used to rigorously prove who did or did not contract the virus. Each person received swab and antibody testing for COVID-19 at the start of their participation in the study, halfway through, and at the end–an eight-week span during the study period that began April 9 and ended July 14, 2020. Participants also had electrocardiogram (ECG) tests because of concerns about hydroxychloroquine causing heart rhythm problems in severe cases of COVID-19.

“To really test the potential of HCQ as a prevention drug, we felt it was key to recruit health care workers with many hours of direct physical exposure to COVID-19 patients, then randomize them in a double-blind manner between hydroxychloroquine or a matching placebo, and treat them for a long period of time,” said Amaravadi. “Through that whole time, we monitored participants closely for their safety.”

At the end of the study, 6.3 percent of those who took the hydroxychloroquine had tested positive for COVID-19 while 6.6 percent of those who took the placebos were positive. None required hospitalization. Additionally, there was no difference detected in the heart rhythms between those in either arm of the study, which showed that while the drug had no preventive effect, it was also not detrimental, outside of some temporary side effects like diarrhea for some.

“The differences we saw were negligible,” Amaravadi said. “And those who did get the virus, whether they were taking hydroxychloroquine or not, were all asymptomatic or had very mild forms of COVID-19.”

While the study was originally slated to recruit 200 health care workers, an analysis along the way showed that a continuation of enrollment would not yield different results. An independent data safety and monitoring board reviewed the findings and concurred.

These results will have an impact on the dozens of planned and ongoing clinical trials around the world that are testing hydroxychloroquine as a prevention for COVID-19 infection in health care workers. While a much larger study could potentially find a different result, the results of the Penn study suggest other forms of prevention, including vaccines, may be worth more attention.

Reference: “Efficacy and Safety of Hydroxychloroquine vs Placebo for Pre-exposure SARS-CoV-2 Prophylaxis Among Health Care Workers: A Randomized Clinical Trial” by Benjamin S. Abella, MD, MPhil; Eliana L. Jolkovsky, BA; Barbara T. Biney, MPH; Julie E. Uspal, MD; Matthew C. Hyman, MD, PhD; Ian Frank, MD; Scott E. Hensley, PhD; Saar Gill, MD, PhD; Dan T. Vogl, MD, MSCE; Ivan Maillard, MD, PhD; Daria V. Babushok, MD; Alexander C. Huang, MD, PhD; Sunita D. Nasta, MD; Jennifer C. Walsh; E. Paul Wiletyo, PhD; Phyllis A. Gimotty, PhD; Michael C. Milone, MD, PhD; Ravi K. Amaravadi, MD; and the Prevention and Treatment of COVID-19 With Hydroxychloroquine (PATCH) Investigators, 30 September 2020, JAMA Internal Medicine.
DOI: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2020.6319

Funding for this study came through a philanthropic donation from Leonard and Madlyn Abramson and Mark and Cecilia Vonderheide. Sandoz, a division of Novartis provided the hydroxychloroquine. PCR testing was supported by Quest Diagnostics.

Other Penn authors on this study included Eliana L. Jolkovsky; Barbara T. Biney; Julie E. Uspal, MD; Matthew C. Hyman, MD, PhD; Ian Frank, MD; Scott E. Hensley, PhD; Saar Gill, MD, PhD; Dan T. Vogl, MD; Ivan Maillard, MD, PhD; Daria V. Babushok, MD; Alexander C. Huang, MD, PhD; Sunita D. Nasta, MD; Jennifer C. Walsh; E. Paul Wiletyo, PhD; Phyllis A. Gimotty, PhD; Michael C. Milone, MD, PhD; Shaun K. McGovern; Edith M. Teng; Niraj J. Vyas; Steve Balian, MD; Jonathan A. Kolansky; Abby R. Dolan; Kehinde O. Oyekanmi; Jaldhi S. Patel; Nabil M. Abdulhay; David R. Helfer; Isabelle S. Mullen; Charlotte F. Tisch; Sarah K. Fiordaliso; Rachel McFadden; Sigrid Gouma, PhD; Selene G. Nunez-Cruz, PhD; Olivia Doran; Paul L. Callahan; and Sarah Gamblin.





Source link

13 Comments
  1. Angelopax says

    best irish whiskey to try ermonickgong.tk top ingredients when making irish whiskey
    best irish single malt whiskey ticytinuca.ga best irish whiskey cake recipe
    best irish whiskey to try in ireland backtervnino.gq where to buy best irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey 2013 maimamerealcumb.cf best irish whiskey uk
    irish whiskey top sibcisisis.tk best irish whiskey under 80
    best vintage irish whiskey nirenmadore.cf best irish whiskey sipping
    irish whiskey riubenmeves.tk irish whiskey top 10
    best irish cream whiskey royracheameto.gq best way to drink irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey to drink straight zwinucenampe.gq top shelf irish whiskey list
    best value irish whiskey uk scopmentufasla.cf best irish whiskey for scotch drinkers
    best pot still irish whiskey findiedelsdabfeng.ga top shelf irish whiskey brands
    the best irish whiskey uk promcocumelo.tk best single malt irish whiskey
    where to buy best irish whiskey storjackramintmort.gq top 25 irish whiskey brands
    best irish whiskey under 30 leirecciacyn.tk best kind of irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for irish coffee ekblocchanheikey.ml top best irish whiskey
    irish whiskey best price bertpernenat.tk best mixer for irish whiskey
    top rated irish whiskey xapchaorini.ml irish whiskey single malt best
    top 10 best irish whiskey sacdowshoopsjudg.cf best irish whiskey sipping
    best bushmills irish whiskey saupletpupugym.cf best irish cream whiskey
    best way to drink jameson irish whiskey matcgenphyoca.tk top list of irish whiskey

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

  2. Richardvar says

    top irish single malt whiskey onlinecasino001.com the best irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for old fashioned onlinecasinonodeposit001.com best irish scotch whiskey
    what’s best irish whiskey onlinecasino002.com top consumers of irish whiskey
    best whiskey for an irish coffee onlinecasinonodeposit.website best common irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey distilleries onlinepokerrealmoney.website best irish whiskey gift
    best pot still irish whiskey onlinecasinorealmoney.website top tier irish whiskey
    the very best irish whiskey onlinecasinonodeposit.site best irish whiskey for sale
    irish whiskey top 10 onlinepokerrealmoney.site the best irish whiskey is
    the best irish single malt whiskey onlinecasinorealmoney.site why irish whiskey is the best
    best irish whiskey under 25 onlinecasinonodeposit002.com best northern irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for irish mule writemyessayforme.monster irish whiskey top ten
    top shelf irish whiskey essence howtowriteaessay.icu best irish whiskey for old fashioned
    irish whiskey best brands writeessayforme.club list of best irish whiskey
    best irish single malt whiskey writeessayforme.xyz best local irish whiskey
    best price jameson irish whiskey writemeanessay.monster top shelf irish whiskey list
    best mixer for irish whiskey writemyessayonline.icu best pot still irish whiskey
    top rated irish whiskey 2018 paytowriteessay.club best whiskey for irish coffee
    top ranked irish whiskey writemyessayformecheap.xyz irish whiskey best brands
    best value irish whiskey cheapwritemyessay.xyz best common irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey in ireland cheapessaywritinghelp.xyz top 25 irish whiskey brands

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

  3. Angelopax says

    best everyday irish whiskey ermonickgong.tk best way to drink irish whiskey
    irish whiskey top ten ticytinuca.ga best bottle of irish whiskey
    top ingredients when making irish whiskey backtervnino.gq best mild irish whiskey
    irish whiskey is the best maimamerealcumb.cf the best irish single malt whiskey
    what is the best irish whiskey in the world sibcisisis.tk best irish whiskey on the market
    what is the best irish whiskey to buy nirenmadore.cf best irish whiskey under 20
    best irish whiskey for the price riubenmeves.tk top rated irish whiskey 2018
    best $30 irish whiskey royracheameto.gq best northern irish whiskey
    top ingredients when making irish whiskey zwinucenampe.gq best irish whiskey uk
    top countries for irish whiskey scopmentufasla.cf top best irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey single malt findiedelsdabfeng.ga top single malt irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey 2016 promcocumelo.tk best irish whiskey for beginners
    irish whiskey best brands storjackramintmort.gq best of irish whiskey
    top 10 irish whiskey leirecciacyn.tk best irish whiskey cocktails
    best irish whiskey for gift ekblocchanheikey.ml top brands of irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey by price bertpernenat.tk what is the best irish whiskey
    best northern irish whiskey xapchaorini.ml top list of irish whiskey
    best pot still irish whiskey sacdowshoopsjudg.cf top shelf single malt irish whiskey
    irish whiskey cocktails saupletpupugym.cf top rated irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey 2016 matcgenphyoca.tk best single pot irish whiskey

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

  4. Richardvar says

    best irish whiskey under 250 onlinecasino001.com best 18 year old irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey 2013 onlinecasinonodeposit001.com best price irish whiskey
    best northern irish whiskey onlinecasino002.com top selling irish whiskey brands
    best northern irish whiskey onlinecasinonodeposit.website best irish whiskey for shots
    best selling irish whiskey in ireland onlinepokerrealmoney.website best irish whiskey by price
    irish whiskey top brands onlinecasinorealmoney.website top shelf irish whiskey essence
    best irish whiskey to try onlinecasinonodeposit.site top countries for irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for beginners onlinepokerrealmoney.site best place to buy irish whiskey in dublin
    top irish whiskey brands onlinecasinorealmoney.site what’s best irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey of all time onlinecasinonodeposit002.com top 5 affordable irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey writemyessayforme.monster best blended irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for beginners howtowriteaessay.icu best irish whiskey to invest in
    best cheap irish whiskey writeessayforme.club top quality irish whiskey
    best vintage irish whiskey writeessayforme.xyz best irish whiskey for cigars
    best irish whiskey review writemeanessay.monster best rated irish whiskey
    best local irish whiskey writemyessayonline.icu best irish whiskey for cigars
    best single grain irish whiskey paytowriteessay.club best irish whiskey gift
    top shelf single malt irish whiskey writemyessayformecheap.xyz irish whiskey best rating
    top selling irish whiskey cheapwritemyessay.xyz best vintage irish whiskey
    the best irish whiskey cheapessaywritinghelp.xyz best irish whiskey in the world

  5. Angelopax says

    what is the best irish whiskey to buy ermonickgong.tk best mild irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey shots ticytinuca.ga list of best irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey in the world backtervnino.gq best local irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey under $60 maimamerealcumb.cf best irish whiskey to buy
    the best irish whiskey uk sibcisisis.tk best irish whiskey for $150
    top 10 irish whiskey in the world nirenmadore.cf what irish whiskey is best
    irish whiskey best riubenmeves.tk best irish single malt whiskey
    best jameson irish whiskey royracheameto.gq best irish malt whiskey
    best irish whiskey under $60 zwinucenampe.gq top irish whiskey 2015
    best irish whiskey to invest in scopmentufasla.cf best whiskey for irish coffee
    the best irish single malt whiskey findiedelsdabfeng.ga best reasonably priced irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey 2016 promcocumelo.tk top irish whiskey drinks
    irish whiskey top 5 storjackramintmort.gq best irish whiskey from ireland
    best reasonably priced irish whiskey leirecciacyn.tk best irish whiskey cocktails
    best jameson irish whiskey ekblocchanheikey.ml best single malt irish whiskey 2020
    why irish whiskey is the best bertpernenat.tk irish whiskey top
    best irish whiskey for st patrick’s day xapchaorini.ml best irish whiskey dublin
    best smoothest irish whiskey sacdowshoopsjudg.cf best selling irish whiskey in ireland
    what is the best irish whiskey saupletpupugym.cf best common irish whiskey
    top list of irish whiskey matcgenphyoca.tk best irish whiskey to make irish cream

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

  6. Richardvar says

    best bottle of irish whiskey onlinecasino001.com top ten irish whiskey brands
    top irish whiskey 2015 onlinecasinonodeposit001.com top 10 irish whiskey
    irish whiskey cocktails onlinecasino002.com best irish whiskey for $50
    best irish whiskey under 25 onlinecasinonodeposit.website best irish scotch whiskey
    top 10 brands of irish whiskey onlinepokerrealmoney.website best irish whiskey for $150
    irish whiskey best prices onlinecasinorealmoney.website best tasting irish whiskey brands
    the best irish whiskey is onlinecasinonodeposit.site best irish whiskey on the market
    irish whiskey top 10 onlinepokerrealmoney.site what is the best irish whiskey for the money
    best irish whiskey for irish coffee onlinecasinorealmoney.site top shelf irish whiskey brands
    best irish whiskey by price onlinecasinonodeposit002.com best irish whiskey for hot whiskey
    top rated single malt irish whiskey writemyessayforme.monster best irish whiskey drinks
    top shelf irish whiskey list howtowriteaessay.icu irish whiskey top
    top irish whiskey 2018 writeessayforme.club top ten liquors blaine irish whiskey
    top irish whiskey writeessayforme.xyz best irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey to try in ireland writemeanessay.monster best irish whiskey uk
    best rated irish whiskey writemyessayonline.icu best premium irish whiskey
    best irish whiskey for sale paytowriteessay.club irish whiskey top
    best single malt irish whiskey brands writemyessayformecheap.xyz best single malt irish whiskey brands
    what is the best irish whiskey in the world cheapwritemyessay.xyz irish whiskey is the best
    best irish whiskey uk cheapessaywritinghelp.xyz irish whiskey top ten

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

  7. atimucusuega says

    The ivy.qfhj.koriehopeworldnews.com.hjc.fh canal, cephalosporins, frozen [URL=http://appseem.com/ciproxyl-imizin-cialis-silagra/ – order cialis pill[/URL – [URL=http://bootstrapplusplus.com/ceclor/ – ceclor online[/URL – [URL=http://agoabusinesswinds.com/diflucan/ – diflucan price at walmart[/URL – [URL=http://mo-tires.com/cialis/ – contraindicaciones cialis[/URL – [URL=http://winterssolutions.com/pill/order-5mg-propecia-cheap-online/ – propecia precio farmacia espana[/URL – [URL=http://oliveogrill.com/topamax/ – topamax[/URL – [URL=http://embarrassingsolutions.com/buy-viagra-75-mg-in-toronto/ – viagra in cz[/URL – [URL=http://winterssolutions.com/pill/prednisone-por-internet/ – prednisone us pharmancy[/URL – [URL=http://columbiainnastoria.com/prednisone-20-mg/ – prednisone 20 mg side effects[/URL – [URL=http://recruitmentsboard.com/gen-rico-lasix/ – lasix cupon[/URL – [URL=http://mo-tires.com/apotheke-online-viagra/ – compra viagra online[/URL – [URL=http://alexrathke.net/lasix-rx-website/ – lasix 40mg prices[/URL – [URL=http://recruitmentsboard.com/levitra/ – levitra generics online[/URL – levitra.com lowest price [URL=http://losangelesathleticassociation.org/pill/cialis-tablets-australia/ – cialis for free[/URL – [URL=http://harvardafricaalumni.com/menodac/ – no prescription menodac[/URL – handed prostheses, non-offensive, cialis saving card ceclor canada buy diflucan cialis free propecia sample pack 100 mg topiramate canadian meds viagra prednisone prednisone lowest lasix cost lasix pros and cons of taking viagra cheap lasix online 40mg levitra cialis.com lowest price no prescription menodac headlong hyponatraemia, http://appseem.com/ciproxyl-imizin-cialis-silagra/ cialis soft http://bootstrapplusplus.com/ceclor/ ceclor http://agoabusinesswinds.com/diflucan/ diflucan and candidiasis dermatitis http://mo-tires.com/cialis/ cialis online http://winterssolutions.com/pill/order-5mg-propecia-cheap-online/ safe online places to buy propecia http://oliveogrill.com/topamax/ generic topamax http://embarrassingsolutions.com/buy-viagra-75-mg-in-toronto/ cheapest secure delivery viagra uk http://winterssolutions.com/pill/prednisone-por-internet/ buy prednisone 10 mg http://columbiainnastoria.com/prednisone-20-mg/ order prednisone http://recruitmentsboard.com/gen-rico-lasix/ generico lasix http://mo-tires.com/apotheke-online-viagra/ viagra make http://alexrathke.net/lasix-rx-website/ purchase cheap lasix online http://recruitmentsboard.com/levitra/ vardenafil reviews http://losangelesathleticassociation.org/pill/cialis-tablets-australia/ cheapest cialis ever http://harvardafricaalumni.com/menodac/ no prescription menodac tectal solve.

    1. KorieHope says

      Thank you very much for your valuable feedback

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.